Player Design Introduction

4

June 21, 2011 by Jeff

When it comes to D&D design is typically the realm of two groups of people DMs and…well…game designers. I say, however, that it’s time for players to take a turn at the design wheel as well. That said, there are a few things to keep in mind if you want to dabble in game design as a D&D player. First, there are some things players SHOULD try to design and some things that they shouldn’t. Second, TALK TO YOUR DM FIRST or be prepared for the DM to say “no” and watch your work be for nothing. If you are okay with that…go for it. Some people (myself included) find design fun when the inspiration hits regardless of if it sees use in my game.

As a player you aren’t going to be dabbling in encounter design, campaign design (unless it’s a collaborative sandbox game, but that’s a whole different topic), and seldom will monster design come into play. Although I could see a situation where you’re playing a mad wizard making his own creations to unleash on the world…to save it, I’m sure. That’s a rare enough situation, however, so this is probably about all the time I’m likely to spend on it.

That said, sometimes there are things you can, and even should, given the right circumstances, be designing. Feats, magic items (or mundane items, I suppose), paragon paths, epic destinies, themes, or even classes/powers. These are all things that PCs can easily either be doing/creating in game or that helps express who they are.

Sometimes, you see, there is an idea that sits in your head as a player and you MUST get it out through PC creation. You have to play that character concept, but there’s nothing out there that’s already been published that does what you need to do in order to make that character the way you want to make it.

That’s what this feature series is going to be all about. I’m going to walk you through designing things in each of the categories listed earlier. My goal is to give some ideas about how one might go about that design in a way that is true to your vision but balanced and without breaking the game. After all, if a DM is willing to let you do some design work, there’s a real temptation to make your new class, Super-Killer, clearly the best class ever. It heals better than a cleric, gets more attacks than a ranger, and does a rogue’s sneak attack each round to each creature on each attack. But if you do this, no DM in their right mind would ever let you play it.

So process, balance, and achieving flavor in each of the categories that as a player, you might be doing some design work.

Before we wrap up and I start work on the first design article it’s worth the time to go back and mention again, that you need to TALK TO YOUR DM FIRST. As someone who both plays and DMs I’ve seen both sides of this process. I’ve seen it work and I’ve seen it fail. So before you design, be prepared to go to your DM, explain what you’d like to design and why you’d like to design it. The DM might be able to discuss already existent options for your PC that don’t require design, they might impart some idea about what they might or might not be likely to accept in a home-made creation, they might even want to keep the lines of communication open and design it with you (so they can make sure it’s balanced and fits into their vision of the campaign while you get to make sure it fits into your vision of your PC).

I hope you’re looking forward to this series, because I’m excited to give it to you the first Monday of each month.

What’s more, if you are interested in providing requests I’ll likely create some of these things as examples along the way. Leave a comment and I’ll see what I can do. Leave an email address and I might even contact you to get more information.

About these ads

4 thoughts on “Player Design Introduction

  1. The RPG Guy says:

    How do you deal with allowing players the ability to create new elements all together? How should a GM go about limiting what they can or can not do? And with what aspects would you suggest a group to start with changing?

  2. When I’m DMing there are two approaches. One, and most common, a player comes to me asking to design something. “I can’t find an epic destiny that really fits where I see my PC going.” Less often, but also viable, if you wanted to introduce it as an element of the campaign. Maybe training features as important and so you let them develop powers/feats and announce to your players that you’re willing to work with them on designing new ones if they’d like to.

    The DM should have a pretty good idea about what doesn’t fit into the campaign. As far as balance goes, the DM typically has more experience with this than player (if nothing else than by virtue of the fact they’re constantly designing stories/encounters) and they also see more sides of the game than players need to. So DMs have to use their judgement about design balance and maybe sometimes they’ll be right, sometimes they’ll be wrong. Keep the door open to fixing it later, treat it like a beta-test. With time it will get easier.

    As for where a group of players might start designing…I’d say it depends on where the players want to start. Maybe it’s one power. Maybe a Paragon Path. Or if it fits the campaign one easy to fit area is with magic items. Your wizard (or whatever) may already be crafting magic items in the game, just pulling from what’s available. There’s no reason that wizard needs to be limited to the Compendium for things they can craft though. Let them use their imagination. Start small, maybe let them grow it out from there if it goes well.

    Maybe I should write an article on this idea from the DMs side for another (DM-focused) site. I have a few friends who might be willing to help me out with this. :-)

  3. Peter Swan says:

    My DM is starting up a campaign where the characters have all been pulled from different universes onto a demiplane in the Elemental Chaos. She’s given us free reign to make whatever design changes we need to make truly varied characters, and I’m using the opportunity to make my surgeon/poisonmaster. Unfortunately, Int- and Dex-based leaders are few and far between(I don’t have access to the Artificer and don’t care for it for this character). So, yeah. Help requested. Email’s aqua.ardent@gmail.com.

    As a DM myself I’m always looking for ways to help the players fully realize their character concepts. I eagerly await the rest of this series so I have somewhere to point them to start. ^_^

  4. [...] the introduction to this Feature series I explained that I think it’s valuable to give players the chance to do [...]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Categories

Posts

June 2011
M T W T F S S
« May   Jul »
 12345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
27282930  
Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 32 other followers

%d bloggers like this: